Could all commentators calling for reductions in social welfare payments and / or pay-cuts for the working poor lead the way by voluntarily reducing their salary to about €200 per week and not touch savings for a year. Now who is first?
Could all commentators suggesting that the public finances can be put in order without any reductions in social welfare payments or pay-cuts for the working poor lead the way by donating year 7% of their salary to a public servant impacted by the pension levy. Now who is first?
Note: "Working poor" is hereby defined as anyone who earns less than any arbitrary threshold between €100k and €25k.
Interesting idea - and one that ties in with a new year's resolution of a lot of my peer group: Live off an amount equal to the dole payment, as much as possible, and see where your lifestyle is breaking that budget.
Can I prod this line of thought a little more, though. If the cost of living collapsed 50% (this is as you can see a hypothetical exercise), would the contributors/readers on this site leave welfare payments at their current levels?
Or if I put that another way, what is the deflation threshold beyond which you would cut welfare payments, given the current state of public finances?
TASC - the think tank for action on social change - has established progressive-economy@tasc to provide a forum for progressive economists and others commenting on the Irish economy. Most contributors are members of the TASC Economists' Network.
All views expressed are those of the individual authors.
TASC believes that it is time to reclaim 'economics' by rediscovering the political, social and cultural in 'economics'. We assert that economics is not, and cannot be, neutral. The very questions we seek to ask, the assumptions we chose to make and the options we decide to recommend are based on a set of values. More to the point, we propose a vision of a different society and polity - one in which people, meaningful relationships and human well-being are ends and not means to serving some other elusive goal.
A new political economy is one that opens up the insights of various disciplines to each other so that 'economics' takes its place in a dialogue involving many different academic disciplines as well as civil society, the world of politics and public discourse.
As Ireland’s only independent think tank addressing issues of social and economic inequality, TASC is developing a network of people interested in this work. If you would like to know more please e-mail us at contact@tascnet.ie.
2 comments:
Could all commentators suggesting that the public finances can be put in order without any reductions in social welfare payments or pay-cuts for the working poor lead the way by donating year 7% of their salary to a public servant impacted by the pension levy. Now who is first?
Note: "Working poor" is hereby defined as anyone who earns less than any arbitrary threshold between €100k and €25k.
Interesting idea - and one that ties in with a new year's resolution of a lot of my peer group: Live off an amount equal to the dole payment, as much as possible, and see where your lifestyle is breaking that budget.
Can I prod this line of thought a little more, though. If the cost of living collapsed 50% (this is as you can see a hypothetical exercise), would the contributors/readers on this site leave welfare payments at their current levels?
Or if I put that another way, what is the deflation threshold beyond which you would cut welfare payments, given the current state of public finances?
Post a Comment